Monday, October 26, 2009

RJA #10b: Argument

Reason 1 It is inhumane to treat animals this way
evidence 1 Animals are treated more or less more like a commodity. They are born and raised in unrealistic living environments

Reason 2 Animals are given drugs to stimulate hunger & growth. This is unnatural and produces health problems within these animals
evidence 2

Reason 3 Some animals body's are manipulated to keep them from becoming a nuisance to the farmer
Evidence 3 Chickens beaks are cut off to keep them from peaking at other chickens, Pigs ears are cut to identify them

Reason 4 Slaughtering techniques are inhumane and unethical
Evidence 4 Cows are hit over the head, which is to knock them unconscious, but in most cases this does not work and they are slaughtered conscience

objection1 Industrial Framing creates a cheaper product for the consumer
refutation 1 By the time these farms get done paying their fines for animal cruelty the coast would be about the same

objection 2 Drug induced animals creates a better product and helps combat disease
refutation 2 When disease first came about was right at the time factory farming was created. The only reason these animals need these drugs that combat disease is because of there living environment

No comments:

Post a Comment